GUDGER
Chaco Canyon, in present-day New Mexico, preserves major
Ancestral Puebloan buildings and landscapes. From the mid-ninth century,
builders created great houses through work extending over generations. Their
planning, masonry and orientation invite questions about knowledge,
coordination and the uses of space. [S26]
Pueblo Bonito is one example within a broader regional
setting. Roads and connections to other settlements suggest that Chaco should
not be viewed as an isolated group of ruins. Yet the precise relationships
between its communities and institutions remain questions for research;
impressive buildings alone do not tell us exactly how authority operated. [S26, S27]
Scientific analysis can add another kind of evidence.
Residues in ceramic vessels from Pueblo Bonito have been linked to cacao, a
plant associated with much more southerly environments. The finding supports an
account of far-reaching exchange. It does not, by itself, identify every person
involved, establish a single direct route or prove that one famous civilization
built the site. [S28]
Chaco is also connected to living peoples. The National Park
Service describes its continuing importance to Pueblo and Navajo communities. A
lesson that ends with the word “abandoned” risks implying that people,
traditions and relationships simply vanished. Changes in where people lived
require more careful explanation. [S26]
Use Chaco to practice connecting different kinds of
information: architecture, landscape, object analysis and community
relationships. None needs to carry the entire story alone.
Activity: Explain the
difference between “cacao reached Chaco” and “a particular distant people must
have built Chaco.”
Suggested response:
The first statement can be supported by material analysis and contextual
dating. The second adds a claim about builders that the cacao evidence alone
cannot demonstrate.
Sources and further reading: S26–S29. Related links: T11; A01;
R06.
Test your understanding with the Cities and gathering places in North America quiz (3 questions).